Death rates are within expected range

I HAVE read the Dr Foster Hospital Guide 2013 and, unlike your grossly misleading headline of last week, it makes no mention of Salisbury NHS Foundation Trust being “one of the worst” for hospital death rates in the country.

It does indeed point to “higher than expected” death rates in the financial year 2012-2013, but over a three year period and for the first six months of the current financial year the death rates are within the expected range.

There are, no doubt, many circumstances that give rise to higher than expected or lower than expected death rates in any hospital and an absence of community hospitals in south Wiltshire must surely be a major contributory factor in the case of Salisbury NHS Foundation Trust.

I doubt that the hospital board are in any way complacent about figures such as these, but they must feel deeply offended by your headline, contradicted as it is by the final paragraph of your article, quoting the hospital’s medical director, stating that “HMSR (the hospital standardised mortality rate) should not be used in isolation.

Using a wide range of indicators, including a number of measures of mortality, the national Care Quality Commission had put Salisbury NHS Foundation Trust in Band 6, which was the risk rating given to the safest hospitals.”

You do a grave disservice to your hospital by allowing such a misleading headline to appear.

ROBERT COATE, Upper Woodford

Comments (2)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

3:20pm Sat 28 Dec 13

Male 70+ says...

Far from it Mr Robert Coate the Journal should be thanked. Clearly things are not right. No matter how you bend the statistics the death rates are UP and should be reported, then followed up.
Who knows, maybe this happened at Mid Staffs with people making excuses for them, then over the years we all know what the outcome was.......
Thank you Salisbury Journal, now chase it up and find out what was at fault.. .
Far from it Mr Robert Coate the Journal should be thanked. Clearly things are not right. No matter how you bend the statistics the death rates are UP and should be reported, then followed up. Who knows, maybe this happened at Mid Staffs with people making excuses for them, then over the years we all know what the outcome was....... Thank you Salisbury Journal, now chase it up and find out what was at fault.. . Male 70+

7:50am Mon 30 Dec 13

Favicon says...

Male 70+ wrote:
Far from it Mr Robert Coate the Journal should be thanked. Clearly things are not right. No matter how you bend the statistics the death rates are UP and should be reported, then followed up.
Who knows, maybe this happened at Mid Staffs with people making excuses for them, then over the years we all know what the outcome was.......
Thank you Salisbury Journal, now chase it up and find out what was at fault.. .
"the national Care Quality Commission had put Salisbury NHS Foundation Trust in Band 6, which was the risk rating given to the safest hospitals.”

I would keep quiet about the care Quality Commission if I them because the CQC ALSO gave the Mid Staffordshire Trust (Hospital Of Horrors) top marks ...and we all know what what happened there!

Perhaps the Journal would like to ask the poor man that had the WRONG testicle removed what he thinks about the SAFETY at Salisbury NHS Foundation Trust!

*Watch this comment disappear*
[quote][p][bold]Male 70+[/bold] wrote: Far from it Mr Robert Coate the Journal should be thanked. Clearly things are not right. No matter how you bend the statistics the death rates are UP and should be reported, then followed up. Who knows, maybe this happened at Mid Staffs with people making excuses for them, then over the years we all know what the outcome was....... Thank you Salisbury Journal, now chase it up and find out what was at fault.. .[/p][/quote]"the national Care Quality Commission had put Salisbury NHS Foundation Trust in Band 6, which was the risk rating given to the safest hospitals.” I would keep quiet about the care Quality Commission if I them because the CQC ALSO gave the Mid Staffordshire Trust (Hospital Of Horrors) top marks ...and we all know what what happened there! Perhaps the Journal would like to ask the poor man that had the WRONG testicle removed what he thinks about the SAFETY at Salisbury NHS Foundation Trust! *Watch this comment disappear* Favicon

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree