Youth hostel plan turned down

First published in News by

PEOPLE hoping to see Salisbury’s youth hostel remain open are celebrating after plans to turn it into retirement homes were rejected by planning officers.

Wiltshire Council’s planning department decided that converting Milford Hill House into four two-bed apartments with 11 new homes in the grounds would results in a loss of tourist accommodation that is needed in the city.

An officer’s report said: “There is a well documented shortfall of tourist accommodation within Salisbury, particularly within the budget sector.”

During the last full financial year the occupancy rate at the hostel, which is currently operated by the Youth Hostel Association (YHA) was 62.9 per cent, which equates to between 15,000 and 20,000 bed spaces a year.

“The youth hostel therefore makes a significant contribution to south Wiltshire tourism and the local economy due to the large number of bed spaces provided, its affordable nature and accessible location on the edge of Salisbury city centre,” the report added.

But the YHA says the building is not viable as a youth hostel anymore and does not provide the service people want. It says it wants to maintain a hostel in the city but needs to find an alternative site.

At a consultation event unveiling the plans, feedback from neighbouring residents was largely positive, but the council received objections to the plans from the city council and the tourism officer along with 46 letters of objection from members of the public and a petition with 373 signatures.

Henry Thornton from developer Genepi Property said they were very disappointed with the officers’ decision and had wanted the application to go to the council’s planning committee so they could explain the proposal to councillors.

Mr Thornton said: “It’s a very unfortunate decision and it doesn’t take account of the YHA’s unique position. They have been looking at this for over five years; they haven’t rushed into it. “It’s not that they don’t want to have a youth hostel in Salisbury, but they have to be pragmatic. It’s not viable to run that type of budget accommodation on that site.”

He said Genepi is in discussion with the YHA about what to do next but no decision has yet been made.

Jonathan Bryan, owner and managing director of Discover Adventure, based in Coombe Bissett, has said he is interested in taking on the site and maintaining it as a hostel. “I’m really pleased they have refused the application,” he said, “and I know other people are too, including the city council and VisitWiltshire. To lose the hostel would have a big impact on Salisbury.”

Comments (3)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

8:12pm Tue 28 Jan 14

Schoolmum999 says...

Bravo Wiltshire Council!! At last they do something right!!

I am a little confused though!? I checked the Wiltshire Council planning website for this application. There were two which appear almost identical. One was approved, one was refused? Any ideas?
Bravo Wiltshire Council!! At last they do something right!! I am a little confused though!? I checked the Wiltshire Council planning website for this application. There were two which appear almost identical. One was approved, one was refused? Any ideas? Schoolmum999
  • Score: 3

8:38am Wed 29 Jan 14

Old Salisbury Boy says...

So Salisbury needs budget accommodation?
The YHA was running with a 62% Occupancy, or in other words was nearly 40% empty all year!
Once again the facts do not support the emotion.
'They" will be telling us again that Salisbury needs a Five Star Hotel and conference centre.
It does not, ask any of the City Centre Hoteliers and they will confirm that they struggle to break even in winter and are rarely full in summer outside of the peak weeks.
Salisbury has a Youth Hostel equipped to modern standards at Cholderton. This fact appears to be overlooked once again.
Wiltshire Tourism appear to be hell bent on closing down the B+B's and small hotels in Salisbury by allowing in the cheap national chains under the guise of expanding the accommodation offer.
Once again an example of not listening to those involved!
So Salisbury needs budget accommodation? The YHA was running with a 62% Occupancy, or in other words was nearly 40% empty all year! Once again the facts do not support the emotion. 'They" will be telling us again that Salisbury needs a Five Star Hotel and conference centre. It does not, ask any of the City Centre Hoteliers and they will confirm that they struggle to break even in winter and are rarely full in summer outside of the peak weeks. Salisbury has a Youth Hostel equipped to modern standards at Cholderton. This fact appears to be overlooked once again. Wiltshire Tourism appear to be hell bent on closing down the B+B's and small hotels in Salisbury by allowing in the cheap national chains under the guise of expanding the accommodation offer. Once again an example of not listening to those involved! Old Salisbury Boy
  • Score: -1

5:18am Thu 30 Jan 14

IanMcL says...

"An officer’s report said: “There is a well documented shortfall of tourist accommodation within Salisbury, particularly within the budget sector.” "

Well done the planners!

This Youth Hostel serves a very important tourist element and the YHA should not be able to wash their hands of Salisbury.
"An officer’s report said: “There is a well documented shortfall of tourist accommodation within Salisbury, particularly within the budget sector.” " Well done the planners! This Youth Hostel serves a very important tourist element and the YHA should not be able to wash their hands of Salisbury. IanMcL
  • Score: 3

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree