Youth hostel plan rejected by inspector

First published in News by

SALISBURY’S youth hostel will not be turned into retirement homes, a planning inspector ruled on Friday.

A planning inquiry was held at Salisbury City Hall on July 23 after developer Genepi Property appealed against Wiltshire Council’s decision to refuse planning permission for the 70-bed hostel on Milford Hill.

Genepi wanted to convert Milford Hill House into four two-bedroom apartments and build 11 new homes in the grounds, but the council’s planning department said the low-cost tourist accommodation is much needed in the city.

David Andrews, from VisitWiltshire, told the inquiry there is a “significant lack” of youth-related accommodation.

He said: “There is clear evidence that there is a strong demand for hostel accommodation and other forms of youth accommodation.”

The inquiry also heard the hostel, which is due to close on December 31, is almost at full capacity during the summer months, often with campers outside too. But the Youth Hostel Association (YHA), which owns the building, said it is no longer viable and does not provide the service people want.

Planning inspector Sukie Tamplin upheld the council’s decision to refuse permission.

She said: “I accept that the proposed development would preserve and enhance the designated heritage assets and would provide 15 dwellings in a sustainable location. I also acknowledge that the submitted unilateral undertaking would help to facilitate the provision of affordable housing.

“But neither these nor any other benefits claimed, including improvements to biodiversity in the garden setting, outweigh the serious loss of tourist accommodation for the budget sector and in a climate of existing and projected need there is no justification to set aside adopted policy.”

Hayley Stevens, head of estates for YHA, said: “We are disappointed with the outcome. We will review it and take any decision that best serves our organisation.”

Comments (4)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

5:09pm Tue 12 Aug 14

RAFRetd says...

Well done Councillor Margret Willmot all your hard work has been rewarded.
Well done Councillor Margret Willmot all your hard work has been rewarded. RAFRetd
  • Score: 0

2:48am Wed 13 Aug 14

IanMcL says...

That is great news and one in the eye for the YHA and developers.

The YHA have a duty to continue to provide for the back packer community and not some up market concept where they can make more money...and ignore the market for which they are supposed to serve.
That is great news and one in the eye for the YHA and developers. The YHA have a duty to continue to provide for the back packer community and not some up market concept where they can make more money...and ignore the market for which they are supposed to serve. IanMcL
  • Score: 1

10:04am Wed 13 Aug 14

journalist1 says...

Hooray!
Hooray! journalist1
  • Score: -2

8:30am Fri 15 Aug 14

gingin says...

Common sense at last > a planning inspector who actually listened and studied the case instead of rolling over and giving in.
Common sense at last > a planning inspector who actually listened and studied the case instead of rolling over and giving in. gingin
  • Score: 2

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree