Wiltshire Council refuse plans for three homes in Whaddon

2
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

PLANS for three dwellings at the location of a former railway line were thrown out by Wiltshire Council at its latest Southern Planning Meeting.

At a meeting on January 16, the Southern Area Planning Committee discussed planning application: PL/2024/05291.

The proposals include the excavation of a former railway embankment, the erection of three self-build dwellings, hard and soft landscaping and associated works.

The plans, submitted by applicant Mr G Mundy, come after a similar application for four dwellings was refused in March 2024. This application is under appeal, but a separate application for three 'self-made' dwellings was made and brought to the meeting.

Heated discussions from residents revealed a widespread anxiety about the application, in terms of its biodiversity net gain, impact on traffic and effect on the heritage of the area. It comes after the woodland area of the land was felled - lawfully - but to the concern of many locals.

The plans for the three dwellingsThe plans for the three dwellings (Image: Wiltshire Council planning) Martin Plimsoll was the first to speak up, saying the railway line is "part of the history of Whaddon" and "part and parcel of the growth and development" of the village. 

He asked the committee: "How are future generations to learn?"

Paul Sims, who's dwelling 'Beckley' sits on Southampton Road, felt his privacy would be compromised by the development due to one of the dwellings blocking his currently "secluded" view from his window.

He said: "It's not unreasonable we should expect to maintain this level of seclusion and privacy."

Vice chairman councillor Sven Hocking put forward the motion to refuse planning permission - against the officer's recommendation to approve it.

READ MORE: Diocese offices at Salisbury Church House could become homes

Speaking of the embankment, he said: "It’s a bit of a heritage asset to the village, it’s quite clear that the developer does not care about the environment at all.

"The change to self-build [dwellings] I feel is a ploy to get over biodiversity net gain (BNG) requirements."

Councillor Ricky Rogers said: "I went there last week and I was absolutely shocked by the stripping back of what was an established growth of trees and vegetation. I was absolutely shocked and I have said before, Alderbury and Whaddon are a developer's pot of gold.

"Every nook and cranny is being developed and overdeveloped."

An agent speaking on behalf of the applicant urged the committee to approve the application.

READ MORE: Historical artefact not been seen for 15 years to go on display

In the application put forward, the agent said it would be a beneficial development, due to the dwellings being in "a suitable location for new housing to help the overall housing supply" and that the site is likely to "sit in a poor state of repair" having been felled unless it is developed on.

The agent also said that "the benefits afforded to the scheme should be given considerable weight and there are no adverse impacts which would demonstrably and considerably outweigh them."

The committee refused planning permission for the application, but the appeal process for the four-dwelling proposal on the same site is ongoing. Those plans can be viewed here.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos