First arguments made as Old Sarum planning inquiry begins

The planning saga could come to an end soon as a planning inspector decides the appeal outcome <i>(Image: Newsquest)</i>
The planning saga could come to an end soon as a planning inspector decides the appeal outcome (Image: Newsquest)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.
Close Icon

Find, save and share Public Notices that affect you in the area.

Search the Public Notice Portal What is the Public Notice Portal?

What is the Public Notice Portal?

The Public Notice Portal carries statutory public notices published in local newspapers and is the fastest and most effective way of finding out what is happening in YOUR neighbourhood.

Search the Public Notice Portal

BARRISTERS have made their opening arguments at a planning inquiry that could revive plans to build around 315 homes at Old Sarum Airfield.

Government planning inspector Nick Fagan will decide the fate of the proposals after a six-day hearing at Salisbury's Red Lion Hotel.

He will hear evidence on three key issues: heritage, highways and the viability of the homes themselves, plus the associated leisure and commercial assets including a ‘flying hub’, café/restaurant, parachute centre and aircraft hangars.

Wiltshire Council and the applicant, Old Sarum Airfield Ltd, which operates the airfield, made their opening statements on Thursday morning.

Both were represented by barristers speaking on their behalf.

Airfield director Grenville Hodge was sat among the public at the first day of the inquiry but will not make a statement to the inspector.

A similar application submitted by his company in 2015 was rejected by Wiltshire. That decision was then upheld at appeal and by the High Court.

The inquiry is taking place at The Red Lion Hotel on Milford StreetThe inquiry is taking place at The Red Lion Hotel on Milford Street (Image: Newsquest) Christopher Young, for Old Sarum, said heritage assets at the airfield – such as the Grade II*-listed Hangar 3 – have fallen into disrepair while the site's potential redevelopment was ‘wrangled over’.

He said: “The negative consequences of the failure to develop the site have been recognised by inspectors and judges alike, who have urged the parties to work collaboratively to safeguard this national heritage asset and fulfil its potential.

“This is a special site, requiring sensitivity and investment to preserve it now and safeguard it for years to come.

“In its design of the proposed development, the appellant worked closely with Historic England to refine its proposal, addressing perceived unacceptable impacts on both the Old Sarum scheduled monument and the Old Sarum Airfield Conservation Area.”


Read more: Airfield accused of ‘sustained neglect’ over First World War hangar

Read more: Inquest finds teenage soldier died after Army failings


Mr Young said the highways elements of the scheme are unchanged since 2015 – but the council has now decided to object to them.

“It was surprising for the appellant to learn of the council’s sudden change in position when, in December 2023, it raised previously unaired objections to the appellant’s – unchanged – highways proposals,” he said.

Discussing viability, he said there cannot be any affordable homes provided under the scheme but outlined other benefits, such as the applicant making all section 106 and Community Infrastructure Levy payments requested by Wiltshire.

Plans for hangar-inspired apartmentsPlans for hangar-inspired apartments (Image: Old Sarum Airfield Ltd) Mr Young concluded: “The weight of evidence in favour of the proposed development is overwhelming.

“It is a thoughtful, sensitive and sustainable scheme which seeks to balance a wide range of competing interests within a complex commercial context.

“The appellant has engaged in good faith with the council and with the statutory consultees in good faith and with an intention of working collaboratively to optimise and safeguard this unique and important site.

“We now find ourselves in the frankly bizarre situation where the appellant is bringing forward proposals which deliver the council’s own policy, and which are supported by everybody, except the council.”

Hashi Mohamed, speaking on behalf of the council, said “very little” has changed since the former High Court challenge was dismissed.

“A significant feature that will emerge in this appeal is the staggering lack of detail accompanying these proposals,” he told Mr Fagan.

“The ‘care, rigour and respect’ for this ‘remarkable heritage’ is still missing. All the flying has been curtailed without explanation. Hangar 3 has collapsed.

“The applicant did not bother with a formal pre-application with the council. How can this be a rational and efficient way to bring forward proposals for such an important location?

“Instead, Mr Hodge seems to have thought that a ‘divide a conquer’ approach might suit him better.”

Hangar 3, which dates back to the First World War, after Storm Isha in January 2024Hangar 3, which dates back to the First World War, after Storm Isha in January 2024 (Image: Contributed) The council believes at least 25 per cent of homes built on the airfield could be made affordable.

“If the inspector finds less than this, whatever the figure, it would still be more than the zero presented by the appellant without clear, convincing and transparent evidence,” Mr Mohamed said.

Among the council's concerns are the C287 Roman Road to Ford, deemed ‘unsuitable for the introduction of additional vehicle movements’, and the ‘harm’ the scheme would cause to the Old Sarum scheduled monument and other heritage assets.

The appeal will continue with a site visit on Monday afternoon. The inquiry will conclude at the Red Lion Hotel on Friday.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos