Inquiry opens into Tesco Express plans at Greyfisher pub

3
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.
Close Icon

Find, save and share Public Notices that affect you in the area.

Search the Public Notice Portal What is the Public Notice Portal?

What is the Public Notice Portal?

The Public Notice Portal carries statutory public notices published in local newspapers and is the fastest and most effective way of finding out what is happening in YOUR neighbourhood.

Search the Public Notice Portal

A planning inquiry into controversial plans for a Tesco Express at The Greyfisher pub in Harnham has opened, with the two sides clashing over road safety, congestion and the impact on neighbours.

The Planning Inspectorate inquiry began on Tuesday, November 17, after Greene King Commercial Investments appealed against Wiltshire Council’s refusal of permission for the convenience store.

The scheme would redevelop part of The Greyfisher’s car park off New Bridge Road, with Tesco lined up to occupy the proposed store.

Wiltshire Council’s counsel, Edward-Arash Abedian, told the inquiry the authority’s case was “at its heart, about highway safety”.

Parking at The Greyfisher (Image: NQ)

He said: “The site sits on a short, heavily trafficked stretch of the A338 between two major junctions, where traffic already weaves between lanes in queuing conditions.”

Mr Abedian argued the development would add turning movements to the road and said concerns were supported by the appellant’s own road safety audit.

He added: “These are not abstract or peripheral matters. The issues surrounding the site’s access, in particular, are matters of public safety.

“The consequences of getting those wrong are measured not in minutes of delay, but in harm to people.”

He concluded: “A second use on this site may be acceptable in principle. This scheme, in this layout, on this stretch of road, is not.”

But Piers Riley-Smith, representing appellant Greene King Commercial Investments, argued the scheme would make effective use of previously developed land, improve Harnham’s retail provision and help secure the future of The Greyfisher.

He described the proposal as a “paradigm example of sustainable development”, adding that the scheme would create 15 jobs.

Mr Riley-Smith said the appellant would demonstrate the proposals would have “no detrimental effect on the transport network nor highway safety”.

He also highlighted that council planning officers had recommended the application for approval before councillors rejected it.

Mr Riley-Smith said: “This is exactly the sort of development that should be being welcomed by the Council and it is disappointing that, despite Officer recommendation, Members were unable to see this.”

Cllr Annie Riddle, who represents Harnham West, raised concerns about existing congestion, road safety, disturbance to neighbours and the effect on existing shops.

(Image: Salisbury City Council)

She said: “The Greyfisher land would have been an ideal brownfield site for housing, and it previously had residential permission.”

Cllr Sven Hocking also challenged the traffic modelling being relied upon by the appellant, arguing that comparison stores did not reflect conditions on New Bridge Road.

Cllr Hocking (Image: Salisbury City Council)

He questioned whether proposed highway improvements relied upon in documents were secured.

“The appellant states in various documents that the plans are funded, committed, in place and secured,” Cllr Hocking said.

“No, they are not. Categorically.”

He told the inspector congestion on New Bridge Road was already “awful” at peak times and argued additional movements would make it worse.

He added: “Data and statistics are one thing. They live in a world where consultants live. Applying them to the real world, where we all live, is completely different.”

The inquiry will continue with evidence from the parties before the Planning Inspectorate reaches a decision on whether the appeal should be allowed.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos