Last weekend I was in Florence to take part in a literary conference at the British Institute. Afterwards, I was lucky to have some time to look around the city in slightly better circumstances than my previous visit.
I’d gone before at the height of summer, when temperatures were 38 degrees and the main goal was shade and air conditioning, rather than appreciating art and historical treasures.
Florence in October was a far better experience temperature-wise, but the streets remained clogged with groups plugged into headphones, aimlessly following their brightly coloured flag-waving leader.
According to the locals I spoke with, the city is increasingly suffering from severe overtourism, the leading cause of which is cruise ships that park up on the coast before bussing their passengers in for a drive-by look around.
Florence, Italy (Image: Anna Holodna, Pexels)
Read more
- City to remember those who made ultimate sacrifice at Guildhall Square ceremony
- Construction of long-awaited St Peter's Place convenience store gets green light
- 104-year-old veteran helps launch Salisbury and Amesbury Poppy Appeal 2025
- Just Stop Oil protester drove to Stonehenge in grandmother’s car, court heard
Because their time in the city is short, the cruise shippers don't tend to visit the city’s many attractions or spend time in their shops or restaurants. Instead, there are now sandwich shop streets to keep them going before heading back to their cabins and on to their next destination.
For Florence, it is the worst of all worlds: not only are there too many visitors, but their economy isn’t even benefiting from their patronage. In fact, it is deterring other tourists who might visit and spend more.
Back here in Wiltshire, such issues might seem a nice problem to have. As reported in last week’s Journal, the number of visitors to the county dropped by a fifth last year.
That may or may not have anything to do with Visit Wiltshire, the business-led private/public partnership that promotes travel to the region, being defunded by Wiltshire Council in 2023. The new Lib Dem-led council has now reversed this, tasking Visit Wiltshire with running its snappily titled Destination Management Plan to arrest this decline.
However, the fact that this decision was reached without the contract going to tender has led to criticism, not least because the founder of Visit Wiltshire was elected as a LibDem councillor in last year’s election. Indeed, it feels like a missed opportunity not to see what other companies could have done to promote tourism.
The slashing of Visit Wiltshire’s funding clearly had an effect, but I also know of several organisations in the city who felt they could have done more to attract visitors.
It’s great that Salisbury’s main attractions are bucking the trend in terms of visitor numbers, but like Florence, our city also suffers from the day-trippers dropping by but staying elsewhere syndrome. The potential for the local economy is self-evident, but more beds and a stronger nighttime offering remain the challenge to keep them here.
By Tom Bromley
Share